MY DEAR YOUNG FRIEND: Those qualities which enable any man to appear well in
conversation, are among the most precious that can be possessed. To every public man these
qualities are peculiarly important. But to a minister of the gospel, they are above
measure valuable. The business of his life is to benefit his fellow-men. A large portion
of time must be passed, and ought to be passed, in society; and he who is best qualified
to make all his social intercourse at once pleasing and useful, is, of course, best
qualified to promote the great ends for which the ministry was instituted.
But while this accomplishment is certainly valuable beyond all price, it evidently
engages much less of the attention of candidates for the holy ministry than its importance
demands. Instead of `coveting earnestly this gift;' instead of studying daily to attain
it, and to make progress in it, as is done with regard to some other things of less value;
this great concern is left pretty much to take care of itself, or at best, to depend on
the exigency of the moment, both for exercise and improvement.
Every man, indeed, is not qualified to excel in conversation; but every man may be
inoffensive, if not agreeable. And as Dean Swift has somewhere remarked, there are
hundreds of men who might not only be agreeable, but really shine, who on account of a few
gross faults, which they might easily correct in half an hour, are at present not even
tolerable. They pass through life not only without usefulness, but are considered as a
nuisance wherever they appear.
As I propose to make Religious Conversation the subject of a separate letter, I shall
confine myself at present, to some general principles, which it appears to me ought to
regulate all our social intercourse. Most of these principles, indeed, apply equally to
all classes of persons. Some of them however, are more especially worthy of the attention
of those who seek or sustain the sacred office.
This subject is recommended to our attention, not only by common sense and experience,
but also by the Word of God. Holy Job exclaimed, How forcible are right words! A
word spoken in due season, says the wise man, how good it is (Pr. 15:23)!
And again, A word fitly spoken is like apples of gold in pictures of silver (Pr.
25:11). Again, the inspired apostle exhorts, Let no corrupt communication proceed
out of your mouth, but that which is good to the use of edifying, that it may minister
grace unto the hearers (Eph. 4:29). And
again, Let your speech be always with grace seasoned with salt, that ye may know how
to answer every man (Col. 4:6).
Allow me then, to put you on your guard against some of the most common faults in
conversation, and to recommend some of those excellencies, which appear to me
particularly worthy of your attention.
1. In the first place, be upon your guard against talking too much in company. He who
is very talkative incurs disadvantages of the most serious kind. He cheapens himself;
tires his hearers; and of course, renders what he has to say, however rich it may be in
wisdom, much less likely to prove either acceptable or useful, than if he talked less.
Speak seasonably, nay frequently, if you have opportunity, but never long. Contribute your
equitable share to the conversation; but do not allow yourself to go beyond these limits.
`Pay your own reckoning,' as one has expressed it; `but do not undertake, at your own
expense, to treat the whole company. This being one of the few cases in which people do
not wish to be treated; everyone being fully convinced that he has wherewithal to pay his
own bill.' This fault is particularly noticed and reproved in Scripture. A fool's
voice, says the wise man, is known by the multitude of words. In the multitude of words, says the
same inspired teacher, there wanteth not sin; but he that refraineth his lips is wise.
And again, He that hath knowledge, spareth his words (Ecc. 3:3; Pr. 10:19; Pr.
17:27).
I have never known a great talker, however enlightened and instructive, who did not at
length, become wearisome to his company. Nor did I ever know one of this character, who in
the multitude of the remarks and opinions which he threw out, did not sometimes utter that
which he had better have kept to himself; and which, in some instances, became the source
of great subsequent trouble. It is very unwise in a man who bears such a relation to
society as a clergyman does; who is set for the instruction and guidance of the people;
who comes in contact with so many individuals in all classes of society; whose remarks and
opinions are important, and if he be at all respected, likely to be remembered and quoted;
nay, whose judgment on the current topics of the day may have no small influence on the
minds of some, when he shall have passed off the stage of life. Surely it is unwise for
such a man to be throwing out his opinions on all subjects, without due consideration.
Surely it is unwise for him to speak hastily and rashly. And if he be `full of talk,' he
will seldom be, for an hour together, wholly free from rash and indiscreet speaking. Let
every man, but especially every minister, be swift to hear, and slow to speak.
2. A fault directly the reverse of that which was last mentioned, is the extreme of
silence in company. I have known some from physical temperament; others from abstraction
and absence of mind; and a third class, perhaps, from still more exceptionable causes,
wrapping themselves up in a chilling reserve; never speaking but when addressed, and then
answering as briefly as possible, and relapsing into silence again. This is certainly
unhappy for one who ought to be, wherever he is, an instructor and benefactor. While you
avoid garrulity then, sink not down into silence. While you guard against monopolizing the
conversation, by no means give it up altogether. And if you find yourself frequently at a
loss for topics of conversation, take pains to have something ready for the discharge of
this, as well as every other duty, by previously meditating on what may be adapted to
utility in the particular company to which you may be introduced.
3. Another practical maxim of great importance in conversation, is that you avoid a
tale-bearing tattling spirit. I have known some clergymen, who were the greatest
newsmongers in their neighborhoods. They were among the first to circulate idle stories;
to give currency to unconfirmed statements; to trumpet abroad charges of the most serious
kind, without adequate evidence, and were often, very often, afterwards obliged to
explain, apologize, and even retract. This is a shameful spirit for any professing
Christian to indulge; but is peculiarly shameful for an ambassador of Christ, whose course
ought ever to be marked by caution, dignity, tenderness for the reputation of others, and
universal benevolence.
Be not ready to credit, and in your social hours to recognize as true, every ill report
that malignity or folly may put in circulation. If you have heard of any faux pas
in the neighborhood, or even if you know it to be true, be among the last to speak of it,
unless plainly in duty to do so. Let others lend themselves to the ignoble work of
tale-bearing, or be willing to connect their names with the repetition of ill-natured
re-ports; but let not your name be ever mentioned in such unworthy associations. If
authority for slander or for contemptible gossiping stories is to be demanded, let it not
be traced to a minister of Christ, who ought to have something to do infinitely more
worthy of his calling.
I have known ministers who were rash, credulous, and withal a little fond of news,
taking for granted that what were communicated to them as facts, were really so; freely
speaking of them as facts, and, not only so, but proceeding to act on the strength of
them; to administer severe reproofs to the individuals supposed to be guilty, and even
carry the subject into the pulpit; when the whole stories which they believed, caught up,
repeated, and acted upon, were entirely without foundation. It is almost incredible how
little reliance can be placed on reports, circulated even by good people, and accompanied
with all the minute circumstances of time and place; and how utterly unsafe it is in many
cases, even to investigate the truth of them: because, frequently, even an investigation
cannot be conducted, without repeating the story, and thus giving it additional currency.
There are busy and wicked tongues enough for this work. The general rule for a minister of
the gospel is to take no share in any such conversation, unless it is, as far as he can
with a good conscience, to mollify and repress: and then only to allow himself to take it
up, when it is no longer possible, consistently with duty, to maintain silence.
When others speak to you of the misconduct of absent persons, as far as possible, in
most cases, discourage such communications; and when severe censures are pronounced,
manifest a readiness, as far as you conscientiously can, to suggest palliatives, and modes
of viewing the subject which may be consistent with the innocence of the party, or at
least lessen his criminality; remembering that charity hopeth all things.
4. Closely connected with the tattling spirit against which I have warned you, is that
which loves to pry into the private circumstances, and even the secrets of families, and
to make them the subject of conversation. There is a littleness and even meanness in this,
which all people of elevated minds despise; and which I hope you will sacredly avoid. You
will have quite business enough of your own, without meddling with the private affairs of
other people. In truth, no wise man will ever desire to become possessed of the secrets of
his neighbors. They will always be found a troublesome commodity to have in keeping; and
even after they have been imparted to him, he will much more frequently regret than
rejoice that they ever came to his knowledge. There are many things of which it is much
more a privilege than a misfortune to be entirely ignorant.
5. In conformity with the foregoing remarks, let me recommend that in company, even
with your most intimate friends, you avoid the discussion of personal character and
conduct as much as possible; and that you prefer dwelling on those principles, doctrines,
and facts, which are always, and to all classes in society, interesting and instructive,
and the discussion of which, moreover is safe. It was a question often repeated by a late
distinguished physician and philanthropist of Philadelphia, a man as remarkable for the
soundness of his mind, and the extent of his learning, as for the benignity of his
disposition: `Why are you so constantly talking about persons? Why not rather talk about
things?' The lesson conveyed by this question is replete with practical wisdom. If
conversation were generally modeled upon it, the consequences would be happy indeed.
Study the happy art of making all your conversation useful. Conversation which is not
religious, may still be highly useful. It may inculcate excellent sentiments concerning
life, manners, education, etc.; or it may convey instruction, as to facts of great value.
Where you have an opportunity of selecting topics of conversation yourself, make a point
of introducing such as shall be adapted to benefit, as well as gratify those whom you
address. And even where you are compelled or induced to accept of those which have been
introduced by others, try to give them an instructive turn. Especially study the happy art
of making your conversation useful to young people as often as you are thrown into their
company. A clergyman, or a candidate for the ministry, who has an enlarged mind, and a
good stock of information, need not, and ought not, to converse five minutes in any
company without throwing out something calculated to be thought of afterwards with profit.
Nay, if we had the spirit of our Master, we should endeavor to make every word we utter
useful.
7. Do not disdain to prepare yourself to converse in an intelligent and profitable
manner on whatever may be the popular topics of the day. Whenever any interesting
occurrence renders a particular place, or a particular event in history, an object of
general attention, if you are not already accurately informed concerning the place or
event in question, make a point of obtaining correct information as speedily as you can.
You may be publicly appealed to for information in the presence of those whom you would
be unwilling to appear ignorant. And even if this should not be the case, you may lose
many an opportunity of instructing and gratifying those with whom you converse. There is
some danger indeed, that he who has thus taken pains to inform himself in relation to
popular topics, may be tempted by vanity to make a display of his knowledge; but this is
no more an argument against his gaining the knowledge, and being ready to impart it in a
proper manner, and on proper occasions, than the proneness of many to pedantry, is an
argument against all endeavors to cultivate and store the mind.
8. One of the most important habits to be acquired in conversation is that of paying
close attention to the individual with whom you are conversing. Nothing is more common
than the violation of this plain dictate of propriety. Many are in the constant habit of
either entirely withdrawing their attention, or at least, bestowing a very small share of
it on the person who is speaking to them. In the midst of the most important remarks,
which they are expected to understand and to answer, they plainly manifest, by the vacant
countenance, by the averted eye, and sometimes, even by the indecency of humming a tune,
in a half-smothered manner, that they are thinking of nothing less than the speaker or his
discourse. This is a great breach of decorum, and as unwise as it is ill-bred. It is
impossible to understand or answer that which we do not hear; and very often, by allowing
ourselves to indulge this absence of mind, we lose many a wise and weighty observation; we
suffer many an important link in a chain of argument to escape us, by which we might, had
we secured it, have been largely profited; and even if what is said to us be altogether
erroneous, we can never refute, or dispose of it in any way as we ought, if we do not
attentively listen to it. If you think proper to take the time to sit down by a person,
and to pretend to listen to him, make a point of really listening to him. When you think
that the conversation ought to be broken off, break it off; but while it continues, attend
to what is said. Unless you do this, it is impossible to estimate its value, or to frame a
proper reply, or to adopt the most wise and delicate method of bringing it to a close.
Many a conversation has been prolonged to an hour, and after all, has proved desultory and
useless, when it might have terminated in ten minutes, and been mutually beneficial, had
the parties only given to each other, for that short space of time, their undivided
attention. I repeat it, then, if you would treat your friends with good manners; if you
would profit by what they say; if you would gain the highest possible advantage from every
conversation; if you would save time; if you would benevolently impart pleasure as
well as receive it; if you would reply to what is said to you, in the wisest and
most instructive manner; then pay strict and undivided attention to every word that is
uttered, as long as you think proper to continue any conversation.
9. The foregoing remarks are intended to apply where another person is addressing you
individually. The same general principle applies where an individual is addressing a
company of which you form a part. In such case, as long as you continue to occupy your
seat, attend to what is said. I have known many persons who, in such circumstances, in the
midst of an interesting series of remarks addressed to them equally with the rest of the
company, turned aside their heads; began to whisper to the person who sat next to them on
an entirely different subject; and thus diverted his attention as well as their own from
the speaker. This is, undoubtedly, a gross offence against good manners. It is practically
telling the speaker that you do not think him worth listening to, and is certainly
calculated to embarrass, and even to interrupt him in his remarks. Surely those who are
desirous of doing to others, as they would that others, in like circumstances, should do
to them, will endeavor to avoid such a palpable indecorum.
10. Another radical maxim of good manners in conversation, is to treat what is said by
others respectfully. This maxim, as well as the last, is perpetually disregarded. To say
nothing of the practice indulged by many, of habitually withdrawing their attention from
those with whom they are conversing; there are others, who testify their want of respect
for what is said to them in conversation, in a great variety of ways: by a smile of
contempt; by a half-concealed sneer; by a manifest unwillingness to hear the speaker to
the end; by interrupting him; by hints that his opinions are frivolous; in a word, by some
look, tone, or gesture, not easily specified, or clothed in language, by which we may
intimate to another that we regard what he is saying as unworthy of being seriously
considered. In all these ways, do proud men, impatient men, obstinate, opinionated, vulgar
men, treat with disrespect many remarks which are worthy of their notice, and wound the
feelings of many a modest, timid speaker.
If you so far put yourself on a level with anyone, as to converse with him at all,
listen respectfully to what he has to say. It is very possible that when he has finished,
and before he has finished, you may be constrained to think very little of his remarks.
But do not wound his feelings, by giving him to understand, beforehand, that you expect
very little from him to that purpose; or by anything that shall indicate sneer or
contempt. Do not practically tell him, that you have no respect for what he is saying. Not
only listen to him, but give every thought and word which he may utter, its due weight.
Treat him, in short, as you would wish and expect, in like circumstances, to be treated by
him. In no other way will you be able, when he has done, to answer his remarks in such a
manner as will be likely to be useful to him as well as worthy of yourself.
11. In conversation with an individual, look him in the face, and keep your eye
generally fixed on his, as far as you can without starring, and looking him out of
countenance. The power of the eye, in seconding and enforcing what is said, is
incalculable. Besides, by talking to an acquaintance without looking him in the face, you
forego a great advantage. You lose the opportunity of perceiving what impression your
re-marks make upon him; and of deciding, by his composure, or his sudden change of
countenance, whether you are giving him pleasure or pain by your communication. Many a
discerning speaker, by watching the countenance of him whom he addressed, has been warned,
by its indication, of the delicate ground on which he was treading, and prevented from
making further and perhaps very mischievous disclosures.
12. It is of great importance to a public character, and especially to a clergyman, to
learn the art of opposing erroneous sentiments expressed in the course of conversation,
with firmness, and at the same time, without offence. No discerning individual can
converse many minutes together with almost anyone, without hearing something with which he
cannot entirely agree. Now, to oppose such erroneous opinions is, in most cases, a duty;
and yet to perform this duty seasonably, delicately, and with a proper reference to time,
place, and company, is one of those things which, more than most others, put in
requisition our judgment, taste, good tem-per, and good breeding. Sometimes the best
expression of your disapprobation will be by perfect silence. In other cases, this would
be want of fidelity. When you find yourself constrained, however, to give utterance to
your dissent, let it be done mildly, respectfully, and in a manner fitted to win, rather
than to revolt, the errorist. For example; instead of saying, to one who has been
delivering sentiments in which you cannot concur, `You seem to me to talk absurdly;' or
`Such opinions are grossly erroneous and mischievous;' or, `A person who can speak thus,
must have either a weak head, or a bad heart.' Rather say, `I cannot concur in that
opinion, for the following reasons, etc.;' or, `Perhaps you have not adverted to some of
the consequences of the opinion which you have just expressed;' and so in other cases. We
are never so likely to benefit those who broach erroneous opinions in our presence, as
when we oppose them, without acrimony; with a mild benevolence of manner; and with such an
exhibition of our reasons, as is adapted to convince their judgment, without wounding
their pride.
13. Avoid a haughty and authoritative manner in conversation. There are undoubtedly,
many clergymen who allow themselves to feel in the parlor, very much as they do in the
pulpit; as if it were their prerogative to dictate their sentiments ex cathedra;
and as if they expected to be heard, not as friends, but as superiors, and authorized
instructors. Hence they have habitually, something in their manner in company, which
banishes ease, which chills confidence, which represses free inquiry, and which causes
them to be listened to rather with constraint and timidity, than with affection. Carefully
shun everything of this kind. When you are conversing with friends in a parlor, you meet
them on terms of equality. You are to address them, not as a lordly dictator, but as a
respectful friend: not as having authority over their consciences, but as a helper of
their instruction and their innocent pleasure. Avoid, therefore, in such circumstances,
all harsh, dogmatical expressions and tones. Do not think to convince by your ipse
dixit, or to put down an opponent by your sovereign authority. This would be proud
dictation, rather than conversing; and ought to be carefully avoided by one who wishes to
succeed, by addressing and treating men as rational beings; by respecting the rights of
conscience, and by convincing the understandings of those whom he desires to gain.
14. As far as you can, avoid controversy in conversation, especially in mixed
companies. I say, as far as you can. It is not always possible to avoid it. An impudent,
rough, or vulgar attack, may compel you to take the stand and tone of a polemic, when you
least desire it. When such a case occurs, it ought to be studiously met without heat or
passion, and brought to a close as speedily as possible. But many good men love
controversy; or, at any rate, are easily betrayed into it. They have so little knowledge
of the world, and so little discretion, that they are always ready to give battle,
whenever they see the banner of a party raised. And even if they be seated in large, mixed
companies, and be in danger of having all eyes and ears turned to them; still they imagine
that no disputable sentiment must be allowed to pass. This is a real infirmity. Watch and
pray against it without ceasing. Never suffer the truth, if you can help it, to be
trampled under feet in your presence. But there are many ways of interposing a mild,
conciliatory word in its behalf, and doing it firmly, without allowing yourself to be
drawn into a dispute. And in this case, the old medical maxim, obsta principiis, is
of great value. Be on the watch to avoid controversy, from the first moment you perceive a
discrepancy of opinion. A slight effort may be sufficient, in the beginning, to avert the
evil, which after going a few steps forward, will be utterly unavailing.
Before I take leave of this particular, allow me, with especial earnestness, to put you
on your guard against being drawn into controversy, in company, with aged men and with
females. Never dream that you will be able to convince, or by any means to effect an
alteration in the opinions of a man who has passed the age of three score, or three score
and ten. You do not dispute with such a one on equal terms. If his opinions be ever so
erroneous, he is probably wedded to them by long habit, as well as by strong prejudice. He
will naturally consider himself as your superior, and take for granted that you cannot
instruct him. Of course, you will find it difficult to use the same freedom and scope of
argument with him, that you would with one nearer to an equality with yourself in age.
Many of the same considerations apply to females. In acuteness, wit, sprightliness, and
delicate raillery, they often prove powerful opponents; while the hands of a male
adversary are, in a great measure, tied, so that he cannot wield with unrestrained
freedom many of those weapons which he might properly, and with great effect, employ
against an adversary of his own sex.
15. Closely connected with this caution against sliding into unseasonable controversy
in company, is another against losing your temper in controversy, when you happen to be
either unavoidably dragged, or inadvertently betrayed, into it. Perhaps clergymen may be
said to be peculiarly exposed to this temptation. For besides the various other
infirmities, which they share in common with all good men, they are, perhaps, peculiarly
liable to feel deeply, when their profession or their opinions are attacked. Always set a
double guard, therefore, at this point. Recollect not only the sin of all rash and
unseasonable anger; but how much the exhibition of it lowers the dignity of a grave,
official man; and also that, in controversy, according to an old maxim, he who first gets
angry will generally be considered as having the weaker side of the argument.
16. Endeavor to cultivate an easy, attractive manner in conversation. Not that I would
have you put on the smiling, simpering countenance, which many affect, as giving them,
what they think, a pleasant, social air. This is, to all discerning people, disgusting
rather than attractive. But by the attractive manner which I would recommend, I mean that
frank, courteous, unaffected, benign manner, which invites freedom of intercourse, and
which is adapted to place all who approach us at their ease. Such a quality in a clergyman
is peculiarly precious, and if properly cultivated and employed, may become a blessing to
thousands. Of course, the attainment and exercise of it ought to be studied. And I know of
no means of attaining it more effectual, than habitually cultivating that genuine
Christian benevolence, which the spirit and the example of the blessed Savior so
powerfully recommended. A thousand rules on this subject, expressed with all the point and
eloquence imaginable, and day by day treasured up in the memory, are of small value when
compared with this successful culture of the moral feelings, and the heart.
17. While you cultivate habitual affability, good nature, and benevolence in
conversation, be not too ready to make promises of service to those with whom you
converse. The inexperienced and the sanguine, who have naturally an obliging temper, are
extremely apt to be betrayed into this fault. They feel much disposed to oblige; and they
hastily make promises, and excite expectations, which they cannot fulfill. Be not ready to
promise, unless you are sure of your ability to perform. Be sacredly careful not to
disappoint the just expectations which you have excited; and make a point, instead of
doing less than you say, to do more. I have known a number of men, and especially young
men, in public stations, who were so ready to excite expectation of the great things they
would do for individuals, or for public bodies, and so remarkably delinquent in
accomplishing what they so hastily undertook, that, after a while, no confidence whatever
was reposed in their undertakings.
18. It is of the utmost importance to one whose profession leads him much into society,
that he be not ready to take offence at every trifle that occurs in the course of
conversation. It is a real misfortune for any man, and especially for a clergyman, when
his natural temper is jealous and suspicious, and when he is ever on the watch for some
fancied design to offend him, or to wound his feelings. I have known men in the sacred
office so extremely sensitive to everything of this kind, that their best friends were
obliged to converse with them with a degree of caution truly painful. The most innocent
remark sometimes became matter of offence, and where no one else saw the remotest purpose
of personal application, an unfortunate individual was made an offender for a word. Guard,
I pray you, against this unhappy temper with the utmost vigilance. Never think of taking
offence, until you are very certain offence was intended. Be sure to err rather on the
side of forbearance and charity than of excessive suspicion. Nay, even if you have proof
that there was an intention to wound your feelings, rather set it down to the score of
temporary peevishness, than of settled malignity; and be ready to meet the offending
individual, on the next occasion, with the same serenity and good will as ever.
19. Avoid becoming suddenly and excessively intimate with strangers, at a first
interview, and especially, committing yourself to them. This is a great mark of
precipitancy and weakness. Be not ready to trust everybody. Confidential friendship is a
plant of slow growth. Many people appear extremely plausible, and even fascinating at
first interview, who are utterly unworthy of your confidence, and will be speedily
discovered to be so.
20. Never, if you can help it, put yourself in the power of any man. It is, indeed, a
common maxim, that you ought never to put yourself in the power of anyone but tried
friends. I would go further; never do it in any case, unless it be absolutely necessary.
For example, if it be impossible for you to proceed in a delicate and highly important
matter, without making a confident of someone, submit to the necessity. Make the best
choice you can. But, on no account, let your communication go further. It can do no good,
and may do much harm, in ways that you never thought of anticipating. The most prudent and
useful public men I have ever known, were found among those who exercised the most
impenetrable reserve respecting the delicate concerns of themselves and others; who did
not impart the knowledge of them even to their nearest relations.
21. When you are called to converse on a subject concerning which there is known to
exist, or is likely to arise, a diversity of opinion, in your congregation or
neighborhood, do not be forward to deliver your opinion upon it, unless you feel
imperiously called by a sense of duty to do so. And when you are called to give your
opinion on such a subject, be careful to express it in a manner as little calculated as
possible to mortify or irritate those who differ from you. Why should you intimate that
those who think otherwise are either `weak' or `wicked?' You will not be likely to do good
by such language; and it may deeply wound, and even permanently alienate, many of your
best friends.
22. Remember that a clergyman ought ever to maintain personal dignity in conversation.
This is too often forgotten. Personal dignity, in this case, may be impaired, by levity,
by buffoonery, by the recital of low, vulgar anecdotes, by anything in short which evinces
the want of that seriousness and self-respect, which can never be abandoned with impunity.
Remember that, though it be not only lawful, but desirable, that clergymen should be
affable and cheerful; yet that they can never manifest a spirit of habitual levity and
jesting, without giving pain to all correct persons who observe it. Dr. Johnson was far
from being a precisian, either in his feelings or manners; yet when he saw a couple of
clergymen indulging in considerable mirth and jollity at a dinner table, he said with
emotion, his merriment of parsons is very disgusting. And truly, when ministers of the
gospel, who ought to set an example of dignity, as well as piety, undertake to exhibit
themselves for the entertainment of company; to recite low, common place stories; and not
only to repeat, but also to act their narratives, with all the circumstances of
comedy and farce which belong to them; it cannot fail to giving pain to every mind of
correct Christian feeling, and of lowering the ministerial character.
23. Be not ready to join in noisy laughter against anyone who has inadvertently
committed a blunder, either in speech or action. It gives pain; and is a mark of very
coarse breeding. A dignified command of the countenance is a talent of great value to one
in a public station, and adapted to save him from many an embarrassing and mortifying
occurrence. It is a real infirmity, and, in a minister of the gospel, an unhappy one, to
be ever ready to laugh, or to be noted as a great laugher.
24. It is a great offence against good breeding to be ever ready to turn the eyes of a
company on a certain individual, to whom some remark, cursorily made, is supposed to be
applicable, and thus, often times, deeply to embarrass him. I have often seen this rule
violated in the public assembly, as well as in the parlor. A remark is made, perhaps,
which is leveled at the particular denomination or party to which an individual present
belongs, or at some opinion which he holds, or some conduct with which he is known to be
chargeable. In an instant, every eye is turned toward him; and perhaps some fairly turn
round in their seats, to gaze with a smirk or a sneer at the supposed delinquent. There is
something so indelicate in this, that a person of truly correct feeling will by no means
allow himself to practice it.
25. I have long thought that the practice of retailing anecdotes was one by far too
much indulged by many clergymen. To be able to tell a seasonable, appropriate, short and
pointed anecdote, now and then, is certainly an accomplishment by no means to be despised,
and very proper to be indulged by a clergyman, as well as by any other man. But to abound
in them; to be continually resorting to them; to make the repetition of them a favorite
amusement, and one of our characteristics, is indeed unworthy of a Christian minister. I
could name clergymen who have a set of anecdotes, which they are constantly retailing;
some of them very vulgar; a large portion of them old and perfectly stale; not a few
relating to ludicrous citations and expositions of Scripture, and of course, calculated to
make the Scripture ridiculous in the view of many people; and these, perhaps, repeated the
hundredth time, to the loathing of many who have heard them over and over again. A man
must have a better memory, and a richer fund, than commonly fall to the lot of the
retailers of anecdotes, who does not repeat the items in his list, many times over, to the
same individuals. But this is not the worst. The persons in question, by the constant
repetition of ludicrous stories, have insensibly cherished in their minds a habitual bias
to levity, and have come at length to be expected to be the general jesters for their
company.
26. This propensity to the incessant retailing of anecdotes becomes more highly
exceptionable, when it leads, as it sometimes does, to the recital of those which include
the repetition of profane or obscene language. It is in vain to say that he who only
repeats the story, is not the author of the language, and by no means expresses his
approbation of it. If the ear be polluted by the words of profaneness and obscenity, it
matters little who first of all uttered them. The work of mischief is accumulating by
every repetition; and the desire of every Christian ought to be that it never be heard
again.
27. Nearly allied to the practice of constantly retailing common place or unseemly
anecdotes, is that of habitually repeating old and stale proverbs. These, from the
circumstances of their having been repeated so many thousand times, have ceased to be of
interest; and many of them are truly vulgar, so that to be continually repeating them
would be really to subject yourself to the charge of habitual vulgarity. The truth is,
making yourself remarkable for the frequent repetition of any particular form of speech,
or proverbial expression, is alike contrary to all good taste, and good breeding.
28. And this leads me to lay it down as another fundamental principle of conversation,
that nothing in the least degree bordering on the indelicate, or the coarse, ought ever to
escape in conversation from the lips of a minister. If you wish to know how far I would
carry this principle, I answer, if there be a thought or a word which the most delicate
female would shrink from uttering in a public company; if there be an anecdote, which the
most scrupulous matron would be unwilling to relate, if all the world were her hearers;
then let no clergyman venture to give utterance, in mixed companies, either to the one or
the other. His delicacy ought to be quite as scrupulous and pure as that of the most
refined lady.
29. It is one of the most obvious dictates of good manners, not to interrupt another
person when he is speaking; and yet how frequently is this plain rule of decorum violated!
To interrupt one in conversation almost always carries with it an offensive character. It
implies either that we are not instructed or interested by what he is saying; that we have
not patience to hear him to the end, and are anxious that he should come to a more speedy
close; or that we are wiser than he, and more competent to give instruction on the subject
on which he is speaking; neither of which is consistent with that respect and benevolence
which we owe to those with whom we converse. But, while you sacredly guard against
interrupting others in conversation, be not impatient of interruption yourself. Bear it
with calmness, and without the least indication of irritated feeling. Set it down to the
score of inadvertence, of nervous excitement, of irascible feeling, of constitutional
impatience; in short, of anything rather than a design to give offence, unless you are
compelled by unquestionable testimony to adopt this unfavorable construction.
30. Never allow yourself flatly and offensively to contradict anyone with whom you are
conversing, provided you mean to remain on good terms with him. It is always a breach of
good manners, and to many persons peculiarly painful and embarrassing. If you suspect, or
even if you are certain, that a statement made is entirely incorrect, instead of saying
bluntly, `that is false,' or `that is not true;' or `the fact is not as you state it;' how
much more delicate and proper to say, `Do you not mistake?' `Are you not misinformed?' `I
cannot help thinking that you are deceived with respect to that matter.' But, while you
never allow yourself bluntly or harshly to contradict others in conversation, always make
a point of bearing it patiently when you are contradicted yourself. Remember that it much
oftener arises from coarseness of the mind, and ignorance of propriety, than from any
intention to wound feelings; and therefore, ought in common to be pitied, rather than
resented or made matter of offence.
31. Guard against the indulgence of personal vanity in conversation. This is a foible,
or rather a sin, which so frequently lowers the dignity, and interferes with the
usefulness of men, otherwise of great excellence, that you cannot be too careful to fly
from its approaches. In any man it is revolting; but in a minister of the gospel, or in a
candidate for the ministry, it is peculiarly offensive and degrading. Let not the
excessive love of praise get possession of your mind. Despise the petty and unworthy arts
of those who are constantly seeking to draw it toward themselves. Beware of seeming to
court observation or attention. Always remember that the larger your demands on others for
their respect and admiration, the less they will be disposed to yield to you. No man is so
likely to be both honored and loved as he who appears never to think of soliciting or
desiring either. Whereas he who insists on often dragging into view his own excellence,
and who is continually blazoning his own talents, attainments and virtues, will generally
be found to lose reputation just in proportion as he takes into his own hands the task of
awarding it to himself.
32. Vanity, in general, is the parent of egotism in conversation; another foible,
against which I exhort you to guard. Let not the idea of yourself appear to be always
present to your imagination. Talk not of yourself, your plans, your doings, or your
affairs in company, if you can easily avoid it. Do not embrace every opportunity of
relating something to your own advantage, or that of your family or relatives. It can
scarcely be done in any shape, however ingenious, without having an unpleasant appearance,
and had, therefore, better be omitted altogether. Even speaking of your own defects and
weaknesses, will be considered by many as an indirect compliment to yourself; because it
conveys the idea that you feel so secure in the acknowledged possession of higher and
nobler qualities, that you can afford to be thought defective in those of minor
importance.
33. Do not affect wit in conversation. Wit, like poetry, to be tolerable, must be very
good. Now, very few persons are possessed of this commodity in its genuine, attractive
character. The greater part of what is called wit, like most of the versifying in our
world, is but an humble and vapid imitation of that which it wishes to be thought. Never
attempt to force nature, then, in the one case, any more than you would in the other. Few
things are more undignified and paltry, than to see a man impotently struggling with
attempts at wit, when the only thing really ludicrous about the matter is, the utter
failure of the effort. The probability is that you have not real wit. If you have, it will
occasionally disclose itself in spite of your efforts to repress it. And after all, it is
not a very desirable accomplishment for a minister of the gospel. It has been commonly
found to be a snare rather than a treasure to those who really possessed it.
34. Do not indulge pedantry in conversation. By this you will understand me to mean a
formal and unseasonable ostentation of learning; a fault into which men of superficial
knowledge, more particularly professional men, are extremely apt to fall, and with which
some clergymen, and especially young clergymen, are frequently chargeable. If you have
ever so much learning, there is littleness in making a parade of it; and if you have but a
small portion, there is something bordering on dishonesty in vaunting it as if you had
much. The best rule in the world on this subject is, to get as much knowledge of every
valuable kind as you can; and never to make any further display of it than the discharge
of your duty necessarily demands. If you were to hear a physician or lawyer holding
forth, in mixed company, on the technicalities and the recondite lore of his profession,
would you not be disposed to smile? And ought you not to guard against exciting a smile in
others by similar conduct on your own part?
35. Both the spirit and the language of flattery in conversation, are utterly unworthy
an ambassador of Christ. In any man it is base; but in him who ought to be a pattern and a
leader in all that is good, it is pre-eminently base. Yet there are clergymen who are by
no means free from this charge. Their opinions of so many persons and things are either
openly solicited, or indirectly required; and their temptations to gratify the feelings
of many different classes of people, are so powerful, that they are not always able to
resist them. I will not suppose anyone who bears the sacred office, to be so unprincipled
as to indulge in the habit of indiscriminate flattery, which, as it must defeat its own
purpose, is as foolish and contemptible, as it is wicked. But what I warn you against is
that delicate flattery, to which many good men are prone; which frequently disguises
itself under the name of benevolence; and of which, perhaps, the poison is the more
deleterious, because it is so delicately and sparingly administered. Never flatter
anyone. Never make your praise cheap. It is not sinful, indeed, to commend another, where
commendation is really deserved; but let it be bestowed at a proper time and place; and be
conscientious in falling short of what is due, rather than going beyond it. Remember how
inflammable a thing human vanity is; and guard against the risk of kindling it into a
flame. He that flatters his neighbor, says the wise man, spreadeth a net for his
feet.
36. And as I would warn you against flattering others, so I would warn you, with no
less solemnity, against inviting commendation and flattery from others to yourself.
Nothing is more common, than what is most expressively called fishing for praise.
Sometimes it is almost extorted; and what is it then worth? Despise the littleness, as
well as abhor the sin of this miserable beggary. I have known ministers who were in the
constant habit, immediately after descending from the pulpit, if they fell in with a
brother clergyman, of asking him his opinion of the sermon which he had just heard. Where
such inquiries are confined to very intimate friends, they are, perhaps, not to be wholly
blamed; although even then, they are in a greater or less degree, indications of vanity,
and spread a snare for the honesty of our friends, and had better be omitted. But when
addressed, as I have known them to be, to strangers as well as friends, there is a
littleness about them truly contemptible. The same general remark may be applied to those
cases in which, though there is not a direct solicitation to praise a discourse, there is
evidently a door opened for that purpose. I once knew a clergyman, who, so far as I had an
opportunity of observing, never failed of saying, to every hearer whom he fell in with,
for half an hour or an hour after the close of his own sermon, Sabbath after Sabbath,
`We've had a very solemn subject today.' This I have heard him repeat and repeat until it
became perfectly nauseating; and have observed him to bow and smile with much complacency,
when his own indirect compliment to his sermon, drew from one good-natured
auditor after
another, a dose of flattery.
37. Do not speak of your own performances at all, after they are brought to a close, if
you can consistently with duty avoid it. If you appear satisfied with them, it will be
thought vanity. If you profess yourself dissatisfied, it will be considered as an indirect
method of inviting praise. If you merely make the general subject on which you have been
discoursing, the subject of conversation in company afterwards, even with the purest
motives, it will be apt to be misconstrued as an ingenious device to extort commendation
for what you have done. Never boast, on the one hand, of the length of time, or the care
which you have bestowed on your discourses; or, on the other, of the expedition and ease
with which you prepare them. Never allow yourself to talk at all on such subjects, unless
you are compelled to do it. A thousand other subjects, more likely in those circumstances
to be useful, lie before you. If a discourse which you have delivered be commended in your
presence, do not appear either to be too much gratified with the commendation, or to
despise it. Receive the compliment either with respectful silence, with a slight bow, or
with the shortest possible expression of thanks; and, as soon as is consistent with
courtesy, change the subject.
38. Some persons, under the notion of avoiding formality and flattery, give way to a
rude familiarity, which they call, indeed, by some favorable name; but which deserves to
be severely reprobated. I have often known young preachers, when they had become a little
familiar with their companions, in the habit when addressing them, of calling them by
their Christian names only, or by their surnames only; and indulging habitually, not
merely in the freedom, but also in all the coarseness of unbridled raillery. Rely upon it,
this is in general not wise. Mutual dignity, and mutual respect, are indispensable to the
continued existence of Christian friendship, in its most pure, delicate and profitable
form. If you wish to maintain such friendship, be free and unconstrained; but never
indulge in rude and coarse familiarity. Those who are worthy of your love, will certainly
be repelled rather than attracted by it.
39. When I remind you of the importance of maintaining a constant regard to truth in
conversation, you will consider me as enforcing a plain point in ethics, which no one can
dispute. But I wish to go further than this language will be popularly considered as
importing. I mean much more than that a minister of the gospel ought to avoid downright
lying in company, whether the object of the lie be to flatter or to injure. It ought to be
his object, in making every statement, in repeating the most trivial narrative, to guard
as carefully against misrepresenting, or exaggerating any fact, as if he were on oath; to
give no false coloring, no over-coloring, and not, even in jest, to misstate the smallest
circumstance. I have had the happiness to be acquainted with a few men whose habits were
of this kind; and it was delightful to observe what weight it imparted to their word; and
how completely they were de-livered from all those troublesome explanations and
retractions, to which the less scrupulous were constantly exposed.
40. Be strictly attentive to the circumstances of time, place, and company in
conversation. Look round the room, before you introduce a particular new topic, and ask
yourself, whether it is a suitable one for that company; or, whether there be any
individuals present to whom it may be peculiarly unwelcome or embarrassing. There is an
old French proverb, the import of which is, be careful never to mention a rope in the
family of a man who has been hanged. It is a proverb full of good sense, and
social delicacy. Yet nothing is more common than to see persons of absent or coarse minds,
violating this rule. They introduce subjects, or indulge remarks, calculated to wound the
feelings of some of the most estimable individuals present; and this, not for the laudable
purpose of benefiting the individuals in question, or of bearing an honest testimony
against vice; but from mere inadvertence or want of feeling. Think, therefore, before you
speak, not only what you are about to say, but also to whom you are about to address it.
It is said that Bishop Burnett was so apt to wound the feelings of those with whom he was
conversing, by an infraction of this rule, from mere absence of mind, that some of his
best friends were afraid of introducing him to distinguished strangers, lest he should
embarrass them as well as himself by an infirmity, which, if its effects had not been
sometimes painful, would have been often unspeakably ludicrous. Direct particular
attention to this object; and it will soon become as much a fixed habit of your mind to
advert to the persons addressed in every conversation, as to any other circumstances
attending the communication.
41. When any persons impart to you a knowledge of facts in confidence, make a point of
being delicately faithful to the trust committed to you. It not unfrequently happens that
the sick and the dying; persons in difficulty and distresses; and persons under anxiety of
mind respecting their eternal state, make communications in confidence to ministers of the
gospel; under the impression that they, of all men, may be most safely trusted. In every
such case, preserve the most inviolable secrecy. But there are many other cases, in which,
though no formal injunction of secrecy is expressed, still it ought by all means to be
understood, by every delicately prudent mind. We all know how frequently, and with what
strict honor, professional secrets are kept by lawyers and physicians; and I have long
been of the opinion that habits of more strict reserve than have commonly been thought
needful, ought to be maintained by clergymen, with regard to all communications made to
them as such, whether formally confidential or not; and that even after an ordinary
conversation on any delicate or important subject, it is always best to avoid repeating
what has been communicated. No one can tell how many things may occur which may render it
peculiarly important that he should have kept it to himself. You may publish your own
secrets; but you have no right to publish those of others. In general, a public man ought
to repeat very little of what is communicated to him. It can do no harm, in common cases,
to keep it secret, while the mischiefs of disclosing it may be endless.
43. It is the fault of many to be loud, and even boisterous in conversation. If the
company be ever so large, the moment they become a little engaged and animated, they speak
loud enough not only to be heard in every part of the room, but so as to attract and even
force the attention of the whole company; and that, perhaps, when conversing on a subject
which ought not to be a matter of such public proclamation. There is not little indelicacy
in this. When you are publicly addressed across a room, in such a manner as plainly
evinces a desire that the whole company should hear your answer, let your reply be
audible, but not loud. Let mildness and dignity mark every word, but not loud.
43. Guard against the too frequent use of superlatives in your social intercourse.
Persons of ardent, impetuous minds, and especially the young, are apt to manifest an undue
fondness for the superlative degree in conversation. If they praise any person or thing,
they seem to think of using no epithets but those which indicate the highest grade of
excellence. If they commend anyone's talent, they are sure to represent them as of the
highest order. If they would speak well of a sermon, they pronounce it incomparably
excellent. On the contrary, if they undertake to express an unfavorable opinion, the
terms, contemptible, execrable, detestable, are the softest which they think of
employing. In short, the more high wrought their figures, and the more intense and ardent
their whole style of expression, the more interesting they suppose their conversation to
be. Let me entreat you to guard against the habitual use of this vehemence and intensity
of language. It is seldom called for. Men of sense and good taste rarely permit themselves
to employ it. A strict regard to truth generally forbids it. And with respect to those who
are in the habit of employing it, both their praise and their blame soon become cheap, and
at length, worthless. He who wishes his approbation or his censure to go for much, must
not be very lavish of either.
44. Seek all convenient opportunities of conversing with the eminently wise and good,
and of listening to their conversation. Especially when you are engaged in investigating
an important subject, endeavor, if possible, to enjoy the privilege of conversing on that
subject with some individual, and even with more than one, of profound views, and
extensive reading. You may often learn more in an hour, by conversing with such an one,
than by the solitary reading or meditation of a month. Dr. Franklin once told a friend
that some of his most original thoughts were suggested by the collision of conversation;
and that too, very often upon subjects foreign to those on which he was conversing. And
Mr. Fox, the far famed parliamentary orator, declared in the British House of Commons,
that he had learned more from Mr. Burke's conversation than from all the books he had ever
read in his life (Rush's Introductory Lectures, p. 349).
45. Finally, be constantly and vigilantly observant of the habits in conversation of
those persons who are considered as most pleasant and acceptable in this department of
social intercourse. In every community there are those who are universally allowed to
excel in colloquial accomplishments. Now it will be very unwise to be humble imitators of
such persons; but it will, undoubtedly, be the part of wisdom to take notice of the means
by which they attain success; and to make use of what you see, as your own particular
habits and character may render proper. I doubt whether any man ever acquired much
excellence in this important art, without the happy talent of close observation, and, in
this way as well as by his own good sense, making himself master of the proprieties and
delicacies which become the social circle.