Page Date:
02/23/2007
From: Anthology 2:2
Samuel Miller, D.D
See Also by Miller
Revivals
The Stage
Conversation
On other Web Sites:
The
Ruling Elder and Baptism |
 |
Samuel Miller, D.D.
Religious Conversation
Copyright © 1998
Naphtali Press |
[Samuel Miller, D. D. (1769-1850) Dr.
Miller was licensed in 1791, and completed a theological education begun by his father,
under Dr. Nisbet of Dickinson College. He became a co-worker with Dr. Rodgers and Dr.
McKnight in New York in 1792. He served as Moderator of the General Assembly in 1806, and
took a keen interest in the establishment of Princeton Seminary, from the time the idea
was suggested by Dr. Alexander. In 1813 he himself was inducted into the Chair of
Ecclesiastical History and Church Government. From the beginning of his career in New York
Dr. Miller enjoyed a high reputation. "Besides having the advantage of a remarkably
fine person, and most bland and attractive manners, he had, from the beginning, an
uncommonly polished style, and there was an air of literary refinement pervading all his
performances, that excited general admiration...". He was the author of a great
number of works.]
MY DEAR YOUNG FRIEND: To be able to introduce the great subject of religion, in
an easy, seasonable, and acceptable manner, in the daily intercourse of society, is a most
precious talent, the uses of which are more various, more rich, more numerous, and more
important, than almost any that can be mentioned.
That this ability, when it exists in a high degree, is, in part, a natural talent,
cannot be doubted. The physical temperament of some men is much more favorable to the
ready and unconstrained performance of the duty in question, than that of many others.
More stress, however, I apprehend, has been sometimes laid on this fact, than there ought
to have been. Not a few allege that they have no gift of this kind, and, therefore,
content themselves in the habitual neglect of the duty. At any rate, they rarely attempt
it, and think that they cannot perform it, even tolerably. But it would be just as
reasonable to plead, because an easy, pleasant, and attractive elocution is natural, in a
peculiar degree, to some, that therefore others who cannot attain equal excellence in this
respect, ought not to attempt to speak at all. The fact is, the power of introducing and
maintaining religious conversation well, though to a certain extent a natural gift, is yet
capable of great improvement, nay, it may be said, of unlimited improvement; and the true
reason, no doubt, why some persons of plain talents, and with even striking disadvantages
of physical temperament, yet excel in this happy art, is that they have taken pains to
cultivate a talent so peculiarly precious to the pious mind, and so manifestly useful in
all the intercourse of life. To what appear to me some of the best means of carrying on
this cultivation, I shall advert before closing the present letter.
My first object shall be to point out some errors, in relation to this subject, which
appear to me to be prevalent; and this will prepare the way for a few general counsels for
conducting religious conversation, and also for cultivating a happy talent for the
discharge of this part of Christian and ministerial duty.
l. It is an error to suppose that religious conversation must be introduced on all
occasions, and in all companies, indiscriminately, whether the time, the character of the
persons present, and the circumstances, favor it or not. No doubt many who have but little
taste for such conversation, omit to introduce it, under the plea that there is no good
opportunity, when it is really otherwise. But there can be as little doubt, that there
are many occasions, in which no suitable opening for it is presented. On such occasions,
to drag forward the subject, in a formal manner, and, as it were, by main force, is
never judicious, and often very revolting. It frequently has the appearance of being done
as a kind of official task, which is never likely to do good. Be always on the watch for
opportunities of saying something for the honor of your Master, and for the welfare of the
souls of men; but do not think it your duty to compel people to listen to you on this most
sacred, important and delicate of all subjects, when their character, their situation and
their employment evidently close up every suitable avenue of approach.
2. It is an error to imagine that the same methods of introducing and maintaining
religious conversation, are equally adapted to all persons, and all occasions. If I am not
deceived, many adopt the notion that the very same plan of approach will answer in all
cases, for the rich and the poor, the learned and illiterate, the occupant of high office,
and the most unpretending, obscure citizen. This is to set at nought all the principles of
human nature, and to forget that the circumstances of men have much effect in modifying
their feelings and character. If we open the Bible, we shall see ample warrant for
addressing some persons on this subject unceremoniously and directly; and others in a more
cautious and circuitous manner. In this sense, we ought, with the Apostle, to become
all things to all men, that we may gain some; not by flattering their prejudices, or
countenancing their corruptions; but by endeavoring skillfully to adapt our instructions
and exhortations to their several habits, attainments, circumstances, and tastes. Those
who are most intelligent, and whose pride would be most apt to be offended by an abrupt
address, might be approached, and perhaps won, in an indirect and gradual manner. There
are thousands to whom I might safely say, Pray, sir, do you cherish the hope that you
are a real Christian? But there are many others, to whom if I were to address such a
question, I should expect to be shut out from all opportunity of approaching or benefiting
them afterwards. Yet the very same people might, by a little address, be insensibly drawn
into a free conversation on the same subject, and to answer that very question without the
least offence. This is one of the many cases in which some knowledge of human nature and
of the world is essential to a wise discharge of duty. Nor is it a valid objection to this
counsel to say, that, if we follow it, we may be tempted to defer too much to human rank,
and corrupt refinement. There is, no doubt, danger on this quarter, against which we ought
to guard. But the abuse of a thing is not a legitimate argument against its use.
Counterfeits do not prove that there is no true money, but rather the reverse.
3. Another very common error in religious conversation, is to say too much. A man may
be too full of talk on this, as well as on any other subject. That is, he may talk
so much and so long, as to become a weariness even to his pious hearers, and much
more to those who are not pious. This is far from being a rare occurrence; and it becomes
especially an evil, when the pious sentiments uttered, are all of the most common-place
sort; and, not only so, but dealt out in that common-place, task-like manner, which very
seldom makes a favorable impression among discerning people. Guard, then, against
excessive talkativeness, even here. Let what you say on this subject be a real conversation.
Let one object of your address be, to induce others to talk, and disclose their sentiments
and feelings, that you may know how to answer them. Let your part of the discussion be as
lively, pointed, and short as you can make it. Never allow it to degenerate into formal,
tedious preaching, or rather prosing.
4. Once more, it is the error of some to imagine that religious conversation is to be
carried on with a tone of voice, and an aspect of countenance, peculiar to itself. Hence,
while these persons converse on all other subjects in a simple, easy, natural manner, the
moment they pass to the subject of religion, their whole manner is changed. It becomes
formal and artificial; so that you would scarcely know them to be the same persons who had
been a few minutes before conversing on ordinary subjects. This is a fault as unreasonable
as it is repulsive. Why should men cease to speak naturally, when they come to speak on a
subject the most interesting and delightful in the world? Shun this fault with the utmost
care. Do not, indeed, allow yourself to fall into the opposite extreme; I mean talking on
the subject of religion with levity. But, at the same time, let all grimace, all
sanctimoniousness of manner, all affected solemnity, all lofty dictation, be carefully
avoided. The more simple, affable, and entirely inartificial your manner, the more you
will gratify all classes; nor is this all; the more easy will you always find it to slide
insensibly into religious conversation, without alarming the fears of the most
thoughtless; and the more easy to recur to it again, after a little interruption from
other topics.
But, to guard against these errors, is not all that is incumbent upon you in privately
conversing with men on their eternal interests. My next object, then, shall be to offer a
few counsels, which I would fain hope may not be altogether useless. And,
l. My first counsel is, that you make a point of
introducing religious conversation, whenever you have a good opportunity, and that you
abound in it wherever you go.
It is melancholy to think how many hours ministers spend in company, without saying a
word to recommend either the service or kingdom of their Master. Nay, some of these hours
are spent in the company of the truly pious, with whom there is no obstacle to religious
conversation; who expect it; who desire it; and who are disappointed at not finding it
introduced. To be backward in introducing it in such company is unpardonable. But this is
not all. In every company and in every situation, be on the watch for opportunities to
speak a word for Christ. And when you do not find opportunities, by a little address, you
may make them; and you will often do so, if you have as eager, and incessant desire to do
good, as the miser has to turn everything into the channel of gain, and the ambitious man
to gather laurels from all quarters. I have often been struck with that passage, in which
the Apostle Paul, when writing to the Hebrews concerning ministers, saysThey
watch for souls. And, truly, the minister who acts on principles of enlightened
fidelity will thus watch, not only in the pulpit, but daily, and in all the walks
of private intercourse. Let me entreat you, then, to lose no good opportunity of
conversing on the most precious of all subjects. Let your conversation continually be with
grace, seasoned with salt, that it may minister grace to the hearers. You may say a
thousand useful things in private conversation, which you never could utter in the pulpit.
You may answer questions, solve scruples, obviate objections, reprove faults, and
communicate knowledge in the parlor, which could by no means be brought into the
sanctuary. Above all, in many cases of private discourse you may come near to the heart
and the conscience, and adapt your instructions to individual exigencies, in a way
altogether impracticable in addressing a public assembly. It has, therefore, often
occurred to me as a fact equally wonderful and humiliating, that Christian ministers are
not commonly more vigilant in availing themselves of this advantage, and more unceasing in
the use of it: that their minds are not found teeming with good thoughts, pious hints, and
instructive, weighty sentiments, as well as direct addresses, wherever they go.
2. Cultivate the important art of introducing conversation on the subject of religion
in an easy and happy manner. One of the greatest difficulties attending this whole subject
is to begin well. A formal introduction of the subject; an introduction which, as it were,
announces beforehand the intention of talking piously; and which, of course, excites the
fears of those who have no taste for such conversation, ought certainly, in ordinary
cases, to be avoided. No less undesirable is an abrupt commencement of this species of
conversation, that is, suddenly entering upon it, when something very different had been,
the instant before, the subject of discourse. But why should we ever do either of these?
What subject can possibly be started, by any individual, or in any company, which a man of
good sense, and whose heart is filled with pious and benevolent emotions, may not soon,
and without violence, convert into a medium of some useful suggestions on the subject of
religion? The state of the weather; the prospects of the husbandman; the news of the day;
an ordinary domestic occurrence; the return of spring; the approach of autumn; or an
accident on the road; these, or any analogous topics which may be hinted at, furnish
ample occasions for the introduction of pious sentiments; insomuch that a social circle
might, by a person of tolerable address, and of the proper spirit, be translated from the
region of perfect levity, to the region of serious and devout reflection, before they were
aware that the transition was intended. This is a happy art. All may learn it who will be
vigilant enough, and take pains enough for the purpose. With a moderate knowledge of human
nature; a tolerable address; a little attention to incidents as they arise; and a heart
glowing with a desire to do good, the task is easy. Covet earnestly this gift;
labor without ceasing to gain it; and you will not labor in vain.
3. Let your conversation be adapted to the character of the company into which you may
happen to be thrown. If the company with which you are called to converse, be all
professors of religion, there will, ordinarily, be little difficulty in adapting your
discourse to them; for you may speak directly and pointedly on any topic which occurs as
important. Especially, you may enter with freedom into all the refreshing richness of
conversation on Christian experience. If, on the contrary, the company consist altogether
of gay and worldly people, your utmost ingenuity will often be put to the test in leading
them on to instructive and edifying, as well as pleasant discourse. Yet even this may be
done, if you take them by the right handle. When the circle in which you are seated, as
will be apt more frequently to happen, is made up partly of professors of religion, and
partly of those who are not so, a very happy use may be made of the former, as a medium of
conveying instruction to the latter. As it is oftentimes one of the most effectual modes
of addressing parents, to do it through the medium of their children; so we may frequently
speak to the worldly and thoughtless most impressively through the medium of the pious,
who are seated in their presence. In short, study diligently the different tastes and
habits of the aged and the young, the polished and the rough, the learned and the
illiterate, the fashionable and the plain, in whose society you may find yourself; and
endeavor to have a word in season, a set of topics, and a mode of treating them,
adapted to their several characters.
4. Guard against giving your remarks on religion, in the social circle, an air of
dictation and authority. This caution, which was mentioned before in reference to common
conversation, is no less important in reference to the subject of religion. Ministers,
from the circumstance of their being so much accustomed to speak with authority from the
pulpit, are apt, spontaneously, and even insensibly, to fall into a similar manner of
speaking in private; to be impatient of contradiction; and to feel, when their opinions
are in any measure controverted, as if their official dignity were invaded. Let no spirit
or feeling of this kind intrude into your social intercourse. The more entirely you can
divest yourself of it, and sit down with your friends and associates on terms of perfect
equality, as a friend and brother, who claims no authority over their consciences, but is
actuated supremely by a regard to their temporal and eternal interest, the more easy and
affectionate will your conversation be, and the more likely will you be to make a
favorable impression on their minds.
5. In conducting religious conversation, as much as possible avoid theological
controversy. I before cautioned you against the habit of falling into controversy on any
subject in company. But I would now warn you that religious controversy, when you are
conversing with persons with a view to their spiritual benefit, is peculiarly undesirable,
and ought to be avoided as much as possible. I say, as much as possible; for there are
doubtless cases in which it is not possible to avoid it, without shrinking from the
defence of the truth. You will sometimes fall in with persons, who, from a love of
disputation, from ill manners, from enmity to the truth, or from a desire to put your
ingenuity to the test, will compel you either to be silent, or to defend your opinions.
When you meet with such persons, you must manage them in the best way you can. Do not,
however, even with such, allow a dispute to be much protracted. Draw it to a close as soon
as practicable. Carry it on, while it lasts, with all the meekness and gentleness of
Christ. And let them see that you take no personal offence at having your opinions
questioned; but simply desire to defend what you deem truth, and to guard them from
injurious error.
But in all cases in which controversy can properly be avoided, by all means decline
engaging in it. Theological disputes, in the social circle, are seldom profitable, and
often highly mischievous. They sour the temper; but commonly leave each party confirmed in
his original opinion. In your ordinary religious conversation, then, keep as clear of what
are called disputed points in theology, as possible, consistently with conveying sound and
useful instruction in divine truth. When you are compelled to touch on them, let it be
under a practical rather than a polemical aspect, and in terms as little adapted to give
offence as possible. When you perceive the most distant symptom of approaching
controversy, take measures to avert the impending storm. This may commonly be done by a
few kind words, or by giving a practical turn to the argument. It may be easy to prevent
the evil; but by no means so easy to cure it when we have once fallen under its power.
6. You will sometimes fall in company with infidels, who totally reject revelation.
Conversation with them is always a delicate, and often a difficult task. Make a point of
treating them respectfully, as long as they maintain decorum on their part; and even if
they scoff and blaspheme, do not suffer yourself to be so far borne away by irascible
feeling, as to address them in opprobrious language. As long as their deportment admits of
your continuing to argue with them, do it in the spirit of meekness and benevolence. In
addressing them, do not permit yourself to call them by hard names, or to impute to them
base motives. Endeavor to convince them that you are actuated, not by a spirit of personal
resentment, or wounded pride; but by a regard to the cause of God, and their own eternal
welfare. In arguing with them, however, do not merely stand on the defensive; but show
them, on the plan of Butler's Analogy, and similar books, that most of the
objections which they urge against Revelation, lie with equal force against natural
religion, which they commonly profess to believe. I have seldom seen an unbeliever who was
able to stand five minutes before the argumentum ad hominem plan of treatment.
Above all, in addressing them, while you appeal to their understandings, never fail, in a
mild and respectful manner, to appeal to their consciences and their hearts. All my
experience tells me that nothing is so likely to impress them as this.
7. In conversing with persons of a different religious denomination from your own,
there is need of much vigilance both as to the matter and manner of your conversation. In
all such conversations, guard against either manifesting or feeling a proselyting spirit.
Be much more anxious to see them Christians, than to see them Presbyterians. Dwell,
therefore, much more on the fundamental and precious points of our common Christianity,
than on the peculiarities of either their or your church. While they see that you are
deeply serious, and anxious to promote their eternal welfare, let them perceive that you
are not anxious to win them to your party. Agree with them as far as you can. Treat them
with pointed respect and attention; if they appear pious, with as much affection as if
they belonged to your particular denomination; and even if they make overtures for joining
your own church, do not be ready to catch at their proposal. Manifest no eagerness to
receive them. On the contrary, rather show, in all their extent, the difficulties which
lie in the way of transferring their religious connection. However unworthily, in relation
to this subject, persons of other sects may treat you or yours, never allow yourself to
imitate their pernicious example.
8. The introduction of religious conversation among entire strangers, is often very
desirable and important; and yet, frequently, requires no little address. I said that it
is often very desirable and important; for more than once have I known a minister to be in
company a whole afternoon, or longer, with a circle of strangers, several of whom, though
unknown to him, were earnestly desirous of hearing him engage in religious conversation;
and were not a little disappointed to find the interview at an end, without his having
introduced it. Many a precious opportunity of instructing the ignorant, of directing the
perplexed and inquiring, and of comforting the sorrowful, has thus been lost. Guard
against all such omissions. Never allow yourself to be half an hour in company, even with
the most perfect strangers, without endeavoring to ascertain whether any of them have a
taste for serious conversation. There are many ways of ascertaining this, without
intrusion or indelicacy. A cursory remark, or an apparently incidental inquiry, may, and
probably will, elicit enough to solve your doubt. Many a precious conversation has
resulted from such an exploring remark or inquiry. Like the discovery of a refreshing
spring in a parched and dreary wilderness, not unfrequently has a minister of the gospel,
as well as a private Christian, met with a spiritual feast himself, and been the means of
imparting a feast to others, when he least of all expected such a pleasure; when, perhaps,
he was ready to say within himself, there is no fear of God in this place.
9. Introducing and conducting religious conversation with persons of wealth, and high
station in society, is a peculiarly important, and, at the same time, a very delicate and
difficult duty. Peculiarly important, because any good impression made on them, will be
likely to extend itself more widely; and in many respects, delicate and difficult, because
this class of persons are more in the habit of being approached with deference, and, for
various reasons, more apt to be nice, and even fastidious in their feelings, than many
others. At the same time, I have no doubt that the difficulties of this duty have been, by
some, greatly overrated; and that plain, good sense, with a heart overflowing with piety
and benevolence, will be found, humanly speaking, a safe and adequate guide, in all
ordinary cases. My advice on this point shall be short. Never, on any account, court or
affect the company of the wealthy and great. Never take pains to be much with them; and
never boast of their acquaintance. When you are providentially thrown in their way,
sacredly avoid every thing that approaches to a supple, sycophantic spirit of
accommodation to their errors or vices. Never accost them with that timid, embarrassed
diffidence, which may lead them to suppose that you have more veneration for them, than
for your duty or your God. At the same time, let nothing of the unmannerly, the sullen, or
the morose mark your deportment toward them. An old divine was accustomed to say, Please
all men in the truth; but wound not the truth to please any. Let them see that
Christian duty is not inconsistent with the most perfect politeness. Introduce pious
thoughts, and divine truth, to their view, in a gentle and sometimes in an indirect
manner; and let them see that you are much more intent on doing them good, than gaining
their favor. When you have occasion to oppose them, let it be done mildly and meekly, but
firmly; with the air of one who dislikes to oppose, but feels constrained to obey God
rather than man. In a word, I believe that a minister of the gospel never appears to
more advantage in the view of those who are considered as the great ones of this world,
and is never more likely to make a deep impression upon them, than when he makes them to
feel, not by ostentation, sanctimoniousness or austerity; not even by importunately
soliciting their attention to his own views of truth and duty, but by exhibiting meek
decision of spiritual character, that they are in the presence of a man, who regards the
authority and favor of God above all things, and whose supreme and habitual object is to
promote the everlasting welfare of his fellow-men.
10. Never imagine that it is your duty to violate good manners, either in introducing
or continuing religious conversation. This is never proper, because never necessary. If
you cannot persuade an individual, by a mild and respectful mode of address, to listen to
you, it is better to forbear. An attempt to force what you have to say, on one who
steadfastly or profanely resists you, is casting pearls before swine. And violating
the respect which is due to any person, under the notion of promoting, in this way, his
spiritual interest, is, usually, of all delusions, one of the greatest. If you watch for
the mollia tempora fandi [times favorable for speaking], you will have an
opportunity of approaching him, if he be accessible at all. If you wait, with a proper
temper, and with humble prayer, for a door to be opened for doing him good, you will,
probably, not wait in vain.
ll. When you are called to converse with persons under religious impressions, address
yourself to the duty with much seriousness and prayer. Remember that what you say, may
influence their eternal condition; and, therefore, that every word is important; important
to them, to yourself, and to the church of God. Remember, too, that the task of
instructing and guiding those who are asking the way to Zion, is as delicate and
difficult as it is important. It requires much knowledge of the human heart, and of human
nature, and much acquaintance with the gospel as a practical system. Study to qualify
yourself for this interesting and momentous duty, by much converse with your own heart; by
much intercourse with those whose ministry God has eminently blessed; by reading the best
books which tend to throw light on Christian character and experience; and, above all, by
humble importunate prayer for that wisdom which is adapted to win souls, and to guide
them in the way of peace. He who allows himself to enter on this duty without much
consideration, and humbly looking to heaven for aid; or to perform it in a slight and
careless manner, must make a miserable estimate both of ministerial fidelity, and of the
worth of immortal souls
12. Before you enter on the duty of conversing with any one on this most important of
all subjects, endeavor, if possible, to learn something of the peculiar character and
temperament of the individual. There are peculiarities of this kind, which frequently
exert an immediate and important influence on religious exercises. Some persons have a
remarkably sanguine temperament, and buoyant animal spirits, which are apt to impart ardor
to their feelings on all subjects, and, of course, to confer on their religious
impressions the appearance of more decision and intensity of character than they really
possess. Others labor under a constitutional depression of mind, which is ever disposed to
look on the dark side of things, and sometimes borders on melancholy, and even
despondency; and which always prevents them from doing justice to the evidence in their
own favor; while a third class are affected with some bodily disease, which not
unfrequently benumbs or agitates the mind, and creates no small difficulty in judging of
its real state. Now in conversing with an individual who is anxious respecting his eternal
interest, it is of great importance to know whether he is under the special influence of
any of these physical difficulties, or temperamental predispositions. For, by the result
of this inquiry, the course to be pursued must be in some measure modified. The undue
confidence of some ought to be firmly repressed; and the precipitancy of others restrained
or cautioned. The backwardness of the timid should be stimulated, and the trembling
apprehensions of the melancholy and desponding, if possible, removed, by affectionate
encouragement. The wise physician of the body is always careful to inquire about the
presence of disturbing forces in the mind, and prescribes accordingly. In like manner, the
wise physician of the soul will endeavor to explore every physical idiosyncrasy which
distinguishes the spiritual patient to whom he may be called, and address him in a
corresponding manner. If you have not already a particular acquaintance with him, make
such inquiries respecting his habits, life, temperament, and other peculiarities, as may
put you in possession of all the requisite information. And instead of making your
conversation, if such it may be called, to consist chiefly of continued address on your
part, which is the favorite manner of some, resort much more to the plan of affable and
affectionate interrogation, which will lead the individual, at every step, to disclose the
state of his own mind, and thus furnish you with some of the best indications for adapting
your addresses to his case.
13. Be careful to give clear doctrinal instruction concerning the plan of salvation to
those who are anxious and inquiring. I have observed it to be the manner of some in
conversing with such persons, to deal chiefly in tender and solemn exhortation; under the
belief that the grand object aimed at ought to be to impress the conscience and the heart,
rather than to impart doctrinal knowledge. But it ought to be remembered that neither the
conscience nor the heart can ever be suitably impressed but through the medium of truth.
It is only as far as gospel truth is apprehended, that any genuine scriptural exercises
with regard to it can exist. Carefully study, then, to impart to every anxious mind clear
views of the fundamental doctrines of the gospel. Not that, in conversing with such
persons, you are ever to perplex them with the metaphysical refinements of theology, which
ought ever to be, as far as possible, avoided. But the course which I deem of so much
importance is, that you constantly endeavor to fill their minds with plain, simple,
connected Bible truth; that you dwell on the scriptural character of God; the nature and
requisitions of his holy law; the pollution, guilt and danger of all men in their natural
state; the divinity of the Savior; the efficacy of his atoning sacrifice; the unsearchable
riches and freeness of his grace; the work of the Holy Spirit in regenerating and
sanctifying the heart; and the utter helplessness, and, at the same time, perfect
responsibility and blameworthiness of man. Just as far as these great doctrines are
fastened on the conscience, and impressed on the heart, and no further, may we hope to
become the instruments of saving benefit to those whom we address.
14. Be not too ready to speak peace or to administer consolation to those who are in a
serious, anxious state of mind. It is, undoubtedly, painful to see any one in distress;
and the spiritual physician will be often strongly tempted by false benevolence, to
encourage, and administer comfort, where he ought not. Beware of this. It is far better
that an anxious inquirer after salvation should pass a few more weeks or months in a state
of deep mental solicitude, and even anguish, than that he should be prematurely comforted,
and led to repose in a false hope, from which he may never awake. Be not afraid, then, to
be perfectly faithful; to lay open every wound to the very bottom, before you attempt to
heal it. Be slow in administering comfort, while the least doubt remains with regard to
the real state of the individual. Indeed I have often thought that it is very seldom
proper for a minister, or any other pious man, in conversing with an anxious person, to be
forward to pronounce a favorable judgment with respect to his state. You may be deceived
in your opinion, and you may be the means of deceiving him fatally. It is, in general,
much safer and better for him to be brought to a favorable conclusion concerning himself,
by that heavenly teaching, which cannot deceive; and which, though sometimes more tardy in
exhibiting its results than earthly wisdom expects and desires, always furnishes the
safest and best testimony.
15. Be not hasty in publishing the exercises or situation of those whom you know to be
anxiously inquiring. It is deeply painful to observe the frequency and injudiciousness
with which this rule is infringed. A person, perhaps, has scarcely become conscious to
himself of deep solicitude respecting his spiritual interest, and given a hint of it to
his minister, or to some pious friend, before it is blazed abroad; becomes matter of
public speculation; and leads a number of persons immediately to crowd around him, and
offer their services as his instructors and guides. The consequences of this method of
proceeding are often extremely unhappy. Some are puffed up, by becoming objects of so much
unexpected attention and conversation. Others are revolted, and, perhaps, deeply
disgusted, at being addressed by so many on the subject of their exercises, and by some,
it may be very injudiciously. While a third class, whose impressions are slight and
transient, are mortified at being held up to view as awakened persons, and afterwards
lying under the odium of having gone back; and, possibly, in some cases so much mortified,
as to withdraw from those individuals and opportunities, which might have been essentially
useful. Besides all this, it has often happened, that the number of serious persons who
have immediately clustered around an individual thus publicly announced as under religious
impressions, has been so great, and their talents, knowledge, experience, and capacity for
giving sound instruction so extremely various, that they have perplexed, confounded, and
most unhappily retarded, the object of their well-meant attention, instead of really
helping him. With almost as much propriety might a physician of the body, when he found a
patient ill of a dubious disease, throw open his apartment to every intruder, and invite
every medical practitioner within twenty miles of him, however discordant their theories,
to come in and prescribe at pleasure for the sufferer.
My advice is, that, when you ascertain that any one is becoming seriously thoughtful on
the subject of religion, you keep it, for a short time, to yourself: indeed, that you thus
keep the fact, until his exercises begin to assume a definite shape and character; being
careful, in the meanwhile, to attend to the case with conscientious diligence yourself.
When you judge the way to be open, communicate a knowledge of the situation of the
individual to one or two of those persons in whose knowledge, piety, prudence you have
most confidence, and whom you know to have the peculiar confidence of the individual in
question. The case of the spiritual seed is a little like that of the natural. When we
place a seed in the ground, we allow it a little time to vegetate under the concealment of
the soil. He who should go every few hours to the spot, where it was deposited, and drag
it forth, in order to see how the process of vegetation was going on, would be considered
as a very unwise cultivator. So he who, in regard to seed of a much more important and
delicate nature, will not give it time to shoot and grow a little, before it is forced on
the public gaze, acts a part, I must think, by no means adapted to promote the best
interests either of the individual immediately concerned, or of the church. If he would
consent to wait a short time, the view taken would probably soon be found much more
pleasant and edifying, or to assume a character which ought not to be made public at all.
16. Guard against conversing too much at one time, with those who are under serious
impressions. I am deeply persuaded, that, in many cases, the minds of such persons, in
consequence of being incessantly plied with conversation, even though of good quality, yet
excessive as to quantity, have been kept in a state of agitation and conflict, longer than
they would probably otherwise have been. And the evil has been, no doubt, increased, as I
just hinted, when a number of individuals, of different degrees of knowledge, piety, and
judgment have undertaken to inculcate, each his peculiar views, on the persons in
question. I am confident that although persons in this deeply interesting state of mind,
ought to be frequently instructed and exhorted, by competent counselors, yet few things
are more injurious to them than to be annoyed by incessant, common-place conversation. It
is an utter mistake to suppose that they are benefited by being always in society, even of
the best kind. They need much time for retirement, self-examination and prayer, and ought
to be referred much to the spirit of God, and the teaching of the Holy Spirit. A few
thoughts at a time, from a pious friend, clear, seasonable, instructive, and to the point,
will be most likely to be useful. After receiving these, at suitable intervals, they ought
to be left much in their closets, with their Bibles and their God; and to be frequently
told to look rather to the Savior than to man for help.
17. If, after becoming a pastor, you should be so happy as to know of any considerable
number of individuals in your congregation who are beginning to think seriously on the
subject of religion, it may become desirable to convene them weekly, or as often as
convenient, for the subject of receiving instruction and exhortation together. This
practice has been much recommended by experience, and is attended with several very
important advantages. It enables a faithful pastor to accomplish more in the indispensable
duty of conversing with the serious and anxious, in a single afternoon, or evening, than
would be practicable in a week, in the ordinary method of visiting from house to house.
The appointment of such a meeting, too, may induce many persons who are really in some
degree serious, to come forward and put themselves in the way of conversation on the
subject of experimental religion, who, if no such opportunity were presented, might
conceal the state of their minds, and lose the advantage of being personally and pointedly
addressed. I am also inclined to think that every pastor, even when there is not
sufficient attention excited among his people to keep up such a weekly meeting of
inquirers as I have described, ought to have a stated time, occurring as often, at least,
as once a fortnight, and distinctly made known to his people, when he will make a point of
being at home, and ready to attend to any, whether professors of religion or not, who may
wish to converse with him on their spiritual state. A faithful pastor will rarely pass
such an appointed time without some visitors. And some will go, perhaps, and be happily
led to the Savior, who, but for such an appointment, would, humanly speaking, have lost
their serious impressions, and hardened themselves in sin. Who does not know that, when
the mind begins to be exercised on the subject of religion, the merest trifles will, in
some cases, serve as excuses for concealing the fact? The inquirer will feel, it may be,
that he ought to converse with his minister; but he cannot summon resolution to venture on
the interview. He fears, perhaps, that he will not be at home; or that he will have
company; or be otherwise engaged; or that it will be difficult to disclose to him his
feelings. The consequence is that he does not go; and his seriousness, after a short time,
wears off. But if he knew that his minister, on a certain day, would be at home; that he
would have no other engagement; that he would be hoping and desiring to see persons in his
state of mind; and that his very appearance at the house of his pastor on that day would
itself disclose the object of his visit, and furnish an introduction to a free
conversation; his excuses would probably all vanish, and he would avail himself of the
precious privilege.
If you should ever make such an appointment as I have last mentioned, and, if on the
recurrence of the day, for several times, you should have no visitors, be not discouraged.
Continue the appointment; and give public intimations, from time to time, in the manner
that you may judge most suitable, that it is not made in vain. No one can tell how far
such intimations may serve to rouse up the pious, and excite them to prayer and exertion.
18. Be not too hasty in encouraging those of whose seriousness you have a favorable
opinion, to go forward and make a profession of religion. This is undoubtedly often done
with very undue precipitation. Persons of very tender age, and others, previously of very
equivocal character, have been, literally, hurried to the Lord's table in less than a week
after the commencement of their serious thoughtfulness; without allowing them time fully
to count the cost; and before they were able to put their exercises to such a test
as might be satisfactory to themselves or others. Hence many young persons, of both sexes,
in a few months or even weeks, after making this solemn profession, have found themselves
unexpectedly bereft of all comfortable hope; their evidences of Christian character gone;
their interest in the subject in a great measure lost; and their minds filled with regret
that they had been so hasty. It was now, however, difficult to retreat, and their whole
lives, perhaps, have been spent in a heartless, and of course, a comfortless profession.
It is readily granted that neither Scripture nor reason fixes any precise period,
during which candidates for church communion are bound to wait, in order to put the
stability of their religious character to the test. And it is equally evident, that
extraordinary cases ought to prescribe rules for themselves. But, in general, it is
evident that there ought to be a few months, at least, of serious and prayerful
deliberation, before taking a step so solemn, so momentous, so irrevocable; a step likely
to be followed with so many interesting consequences to those who take it, and to the
sacred family with which they propose to become connected. Let no desire to see the rapid
multiplication of professors, ever lead you to depart from this principle. I have more
than once repented having given what afterwards appeared to be premature encouragement to
come to a sacramental table; but never did I repent advising to a few months' deliberation
and delay, when the preparation was doubtful.
19. In conversing on the subject of practical religion, especially with those who are
not well informed on the subject, be sparing in the use of that technical language, which
many continually employ. I refer to a number of phrases, of standing use in many pious
circles, which, although the meaning intended to be conveyed by them is undoubtedly
correct and important, are yet so remote from the language of ordinary social intercourse,
that they sound strangely, not to say unintelligibly, out of the circles to which I
allude. Many pious ministers and others are in the habit of using this language in a
manner, and to an extent, which I know render their conversation not a little revolting to
those who are unaccustomed to it, and frequently present a serious obstacle in the way of
their acceptance and usefulness.
As it is desirable not to be misunderstood on a subject so important, I think it proper
to give a specimen of the phrases to which I refer. Thus it is by no means uncommon to
hear it stated, that a great revival has broken out in such a place; that there is a
great religious stir in this or that congregation; that such an individual, or such a
number of individuals, have been struck under conviction; that a particular person
appears to be in the pangs of the new birth; that a person whose anxiety on the
subject of religion is very great has been roughly handled, but is likely to be brought
through; that such another has been happily brought through; that so many, in a
certain place, are brought under conviction, and so many have obtained hopes,
etc. Now, although I am confident I need not assure you, that I am a warm friend to
revivals of religion; although the ideas intended to be expressed by the phrases in
question are, in my view, perfectly sound and scriptural, and infinitely momentous; and
although any one who is capable of ridiculing these ideas knows nothing yet as he ought
to know; yet I cannot think that the use of these phrases, especially in mixed
companies, is advisable. My objections to them are several. Some of them are, in a great
measure, if not altogether, unintelligible to many whom they are addressed. Others are
derided as vulgar cant, as terms expressive of the appearance of a plague or pestilence,
rather than of a rich blessing, and which rather repel, than instruct or conciliate. While
a third class are regarded as a presumptuous invasion of the prerogative of Him who alone
can know the heart, and tell the number of those who have become reconciled to him. Would
it not be better to use language which all seriously disposed persons understand and
approve? Would it not be quite as expressive, and more intelligible to many, if you were
to say, that a revival has commenced, or a work of divine grace appears to have
commenced, in such a place: that a particular individual is under serious
impressions, or is deeply anxious on the subject of religion, or appears to
be convinced of sin, or is in great distress of mind: that many appear to be
awakened from a state of carelessness, and to be more or less anxious, and that others
appear, or profess, to enjoy the comfort of gospel hope?
I presume, if you had occasion to interrogate an intelligent stranger, who you had
reason to fear was destitute of piety, in relation to the state of his mind, on the
subject of religion, you would hardly think it wise to begin by saying Pray, sir, are
you born again? or, are you yet carnal? Yet, why not, as both the principal phrases in
this question are taken from the Bible, and as you and I fully believe these phrases to be
expressive of important realities? Your reason, I suppose, for not thinking it wise, would
be, that this language is very imperfectly, if at all, understood by many who are well
informed on other subjects; and that such persons, because they have frequently heard it
bandied about by the ignorant and fanatical, and cannot enter into its precious meaning,
are generally revolted by it.
I am far from agreeing with Mr. Foster, the pious and eloquent English essayist, in his
proposal to discard what he calls, the Theological dialect, the technical terms
of evangelical religion. I am afraid that, if these terms were dismissed, the things
intended by them would soon disappear also. I do not wish a single Bible phrase to be
banished either from the pulpit or the parlor. Yet, I can easily conceive that there are
even Bible phrases, which may be advantageously exchanged for others, more familiar to
those who are ignorant of the Bible, and better adapted, until they become enlightened, to
convey spiritual ideas to their minds. It is, evidently, on this principle that ministers,
every Sabbath, in the pulpit, explain Scripture, by using more common language, and that
which is better understood, to express its heavenly doctrines. But the language which I
advise you to avoid, is not, as commonly employed, Bible language at all. And I see no
advantage, but rather the contrary, in the use of terms, against which many are strongly
prejudiced; and which, if they do not deserve the name of cant, will certainly, by many,
be considered as bearing that character. Let your general rule be, in conversing on the
great and precious subjects of revivals of religion, and Christian experience, to employ
terms which are warranted by Scripture, and the most enlightened practical writers, and
adapted to make the best impression on those whom we address.
20. Take pains to prepare yourself for conducting religious conversation in an easy and
edifying manner. For this purpose, be familiar with practical books, and especially with
the lives of eminently pious men. Take a few minutes to premeditate before you expect to
go into the company of any person or persons on this important errand. Adjust in your own
mind topics and thoughts for discourse, adapted to the cases of those whom you expect to
meet. Study some variety in this matter. If you go over the same common-place, narrow,
little round of remark, in all companies, for thirty or forty years together, you will
soon entirely cease to interest any one, unless, perhaps, a stranger, who happened to hear
it for the first time. Above all, let every attempt to perform the service in question, be
preceded by humbly asking for divine help. Remember that God will be inquired of to
grant us his aid; and that he will not give his glory to another. Remember that he
can render the feeblest sentence that ever escaped the lips of simple piety, richly and
eternally beneficial: while the most able and well conducted conversation, if administered
without imploring a blessing upon it, may, and probably will, prove useless to all
concerned.
21. If you desire to gain an easy, natural and attractive manner of introducing and
maintaining religious conversation, let the foundation of all your efforts at improvement
in this respect, be laid in the culture of the heart. Study daily to grow in vital piety.
Perhaps there is nothing more indispensable to the happy discharge of the duty under
consideration than that the heart continually prompt and speak; that heart-felt emotion
and affection dictate every word, and tone, and look, while engaged in addressing a
fellow-creature on the most important of all subjects. Truly, without active, fervent love
to God, and to the souls of men, it will be vain to hope for the attainment of this happy
art, in any considerable degree. But if your heart habitually glow with interest in this
subject; if the love of Christ constrain you; if you daily cherish a tender concern
for the salvation of your perishing fellow-mortals; if your mind be constantly teeming
with desires and plans to do them good; then religious conversation will be as natural as
to breathe. Then your lips will be opened seasonably, unaffectedly, and profitably to all
around you. Then, instead of being at a loss what to say; or being timidly backward to say
it; or saying it in an embarrassed, awkward, pompous, or unnatural manner; there will be a
simplicity, a touching tenderness, a penetrating skill, a native gracefulness, an unction
in your mode of conversing, which no spurious feelings can successfully imitate. The true
reason, I have no doubt, why religious conversation is so often what it ought not to be,
and so often useless, is that it is so seldom the offspring of that unaffected warm,
spiritual feeling, which piety of an elevated character alone can give.
22. Finally, it will be a stimulus to diligence, and an auxiliary to improvement, in
the precious art of religious conversation, if you daily and faithfully call yourself to
an account for the manner in which you have performed this duty. We stand in need of
something of this kind to quicken us in every department of our Christian work; and in
none more than those which consist in frequently recurring details, rather than in single
great acts. Never retire from any company, then, without asking yourself, What have I
said for the honor of my Master, and for promoting the everlasting welfare of those with
whom I conversed? What was the tenor of my conversation? What opportunity of recommending
religion have I neglected to improve? From what motives did I speak, or keep silence? In
what manner did I converse? With gentleness, modesty, humility, and yet with affectionate
fidelity; or with harshness, with formality, with ostentation, with vanity, and from a
desire to avoid censure, or to court popular applause? Few things, I believe, would
have a more powerful tendency to promote watchfulness, diligence, and unremitting
perseverance in this important duty, than the constant inspection and trial of ourselves
here recommended. |
Articles Online
Return to Naphtali
Press main page James Bannerman Rites
& Ceremonies in Public Worship
Thomas Boston
The Evil, Nature and Danger of Schism
William Cunningham
Relation Between Church and State
The Westminster Confession on the Relation Between Church and
State
Albert Dod: Review of Charles Finney's Revival
Methods
Part One
Part Two
James Durham
Repentance
The Fourth Commandment
Introduction
1. Morality of the Fourth Commandment
Excurses: Family Worship
2. The Particular Morality of the Fourth Commandment
3. The Change of the Day
4. The Sanctification of the day.
Lectures on Job
Extracts: To the Reader, Job Chapter One
A Treatise Concerning Scandal
Extracts: Historical Introduction,
Author's
Introduction, 2-2 Public Scandals
George Gillespie
Assurance of an Interest in Christ
Holy Days
Wholesome Severity Reconciled with Christian Liberty
The English Popish Ceremonies
Extracts: Historical Introduction, Gillespie's Introduction
Against Holy Days
EPC Bibliography
David Hay Fleming
Discipline of the Reformation part one
part two part three
John M. Mason
Letters on Frequent
Communion
Thomas M'Crie:
Brief View of the evidence for the exercise of Civil
Authority about religion.
Sermon: Grief for the Sins of Men
Sermon: Christian Friendship
Sermon: The Fan in Christ's Hand
Samuel Miller
Nature and Effects of the Stage
Conversation
Religious Conversation
Revivals of Religion
Samuel Rutherfurd
Against Separatism § Part One § Part
Two § Part Three § Part Four
William Sprague
Danger of Being Overwise (On Use of Wine in the Lord's Supper)
James Wood
Separation from Corrupt Churches
Church Government
Thomas M'Crie: Brief View of
the evidence for the exercise of Civil Authority about religion.
Divine Right of Church Government
Extracts: Publisher's Preface, 1-2 What is a Jus Divinum?
Revivals of Religion
Samuel Miller: Revivals of Religion
Dod on Finney Part One
Dod on Finney Part Two
Schism and Separatism
James Wood: Separation from Corrupt Churches
John MacPherson: Unity of the Church
Thomas Boston: The Evil, Nature and Danger of Schism
Samuel Rutherford: Against Separatism § Part One § Part
Two § Part Three § Part Four
Worship
James Gilfillan, Holidays
David Calderwood, Against Festival
Days
John L. Girardeau: The
Discretionary Power of the Church
Robert L. Dabney: Review of Girardeau's
Instrumental Music in Worship
William Sprague: Danger of Being Overwise: Wine in Communion
|